For families moving to Pittsburgh's North Hills, the home search often starts with one question: "North Allegheny (NA) or Pine-Richland (PR)?"
Both are consistently ranked among the top districts in Pennsylvania, yet they offer distinctly different environments, campus styles, and community vibes. Here is a breakdown of the differences to help you decide which neighborhood fits your household.
1. The Geography: Where Will You Live?
The biggest difference isn't the curriculum; it's the commute and the community layout.
- North Allegheny (The "Golden Triangle"): NA covers a massive 48-square-mile area including McCandless, Franklin Park, Marshall Township, and Bradford Woods. Living here often means closer access to McKnight Road shopping and a slightly shorter commute to Downtown Pittsburgh (via I-279/HOV).
- Pine-Richland (The "Northern Tier"): PR serves Pine Township and Richland Township. This area feels more semi-rural and expansive, with newer planned developments, larger lot sizes, and direct access to the Turnpike (I-76) and Route 228 shopping in Cranberry.
2. Scale & Campus Structure
- North Allegheny: "Big and Specialized." NA is one of the largest suburban districts in the state. It operates two intermediate high schools (grades 9-10) and one senior high school (11-12), allowing for an immense variety of AP courses, arts programs, and specialized electives that smaller districts can't support.
- Pine-Richland: "Campus-Style Community." PR features a more centralized campus feel with a single, modern high school layout. Many residents feel this fosters a tight-knit "Ram Pride" culture where students grow up in fewer buildings together.
3. The Real Estate Factor: What Are You Buying?
This is where the districts differ most in terms of inventory style.
North Allegheny: The Mix of Historic & High-End New
- Marshall Township: Often mistaken for just rural estates, Marshall is actually the current hub for luxury new construction in the NA district. From the mixed-use, walkable streets of Venango Trails to massive custom builds on private acreage, this is where you go if you want a modern home without sacrificing the NA school tag.
- Franklin Park: The "Established Executive" choice. Here, you will find fewer cookie-cutter plans and more custom-built brick homes from the 1990s and 2000s sitting on mature, wooded lots. Franklin Park is prized for its privacy and "finished" neighborhood feel.
Pine-Richland: The "Master-Planned" Lifestyle
- Pine Township: Pine is defined by large-scale, amenity-rich developments. This is the home of Treesdale (the region's premier golf course community) and newer developments like Emerald Fields. If you want a neighborhood with sidewalks, community pools, and a resort-style social scene, Pine Township offers arguably the best inventory in Western PA.
- Richland Township: Offering a blend of semi-rural charm and rapid growth, Richland provides more land for your money. You'll find everything from brand-new patio home communities to expansive lots that feel miles away from the city, yet are just minutes from Route 8 shopping.
Ready to Tour?
Whether you choose the extensive resources of North Allegheny or the modern community feel of Pine-Richland, you are investing in two of the region's strongest assets.